Skip to content
Let’s Talk Alberta: A Conversation About Alberta’s Future
A rulebook check
Updated November 11, 2026

Can the United Conservative Party remove a CA president for not signing?

The UCP has asked all 87 of its constituency association presidents to sign a declaration on the October 19 referendum result. Here’s what the party’s own rulebook says about it, with every rule linked so you can check it yourself.

The short answer

Not directly, under the rules members wrote. CA presidents are elected by their own members, and the rules say who can remove them and how.

The Party Board has one real route: a temporary change to the CA Rules. That change is not binding until emailed to members and posted on the party website, and its temporary effect ends no later than the next AGM, where it may be ratified, amended or rejected.

What happened

This page isn’t about the referendum result. It’s about whether the party’s own rules allow this request, and what happens to a volunteer who says no.

The requestThe party’s executive director sent presidents a combined non-disclosure agreement and code of conduct that includes a commitment to recognize, respect and abide by the referendum result, with a Friday deadline.
The pushbackPresidents on both sides of the referendum question have objected, calling it an unfair limit on their speech.
The open questionAsked what happens to a president who doesn’t sign, the party didn’t say.
Not the first timeCandidates for the provincial board were asked to sign a similar declaration as part of the candidate process. CA presidents are different: they already hold elected office.

Source: CBC News, November 2026

Every route to removing a CA president

There are six ways someone could try to take a riding president out of office. Pick one to see who decides, what it takes, and whether it fits a president who simply didn’t sign.

Party Board policy

No removal power, as written
Who decides
The Party Board
What it takes
A policy or procedure under the board’s general power to govern the party and its CAs.
Does it fit?
Bylaw 7.10.2 is a power to set policy. It says nothing about removing CA officers. The Party Board’s removal power in Bylaw 7.8 covers its own Directors and Officers, other than the Leader, only. Board policy can’t override the CA Rules members ratified, and each CA’s affairs are under the control of its members.
Bylaws 7.8, 7.10.2, 9.3, 10.
Clear route in the rules Exists, but with conditions or open questions Doesn’t fit, as written

Which rule wins

UCP governance involves applicable law, the Bylaws and member-ratified constitutional documents. Where the CA Rules conflict with the Bylaws, the Bylaws prevail (CA Rules 9.2). Tap a rung to see what it can and can’t do.

1
2
3
4
5

Both sides of the argument

The party has real arguments. Here they are, laid out fairly, next to the response from the rulebook. Open any one to compare.

“The board sets policy for CAs, so it can require this.”

The party’s case

Bylaw 7.10.2 gives the Party Board power to establish policies and procedures for the governance of all constituency associations. A signing requirement is a governance procedure.

The response

Making policy and removing an elected officer aren’t the same power. The CA Rules already say how CA officers are removed, and the Party Board isn’t on that list. Board policy sits below the CA Rules on the ladder, so it can’t override them.

“Directors already have to sign party documents or their election is void.”

The party’s case

CA Rule 7.6 says a director who doesn’t sign the party’s neutrality and confidentiality documents has their election declared null and void. This declaration is part of an NDA and code of conduct.

The response

Rule 7.6 is a one-time condition: directors sign after they’re elected, before their next board meeting. It doesn’t give the party a standing power to add new conditions mid-term. Its scope is neutrality and confidentiality, and a position on a referendum result is neither. Sitting presidents have already signed those documents.

“The board can change the CA Rules if circumstances call for it.”

The party’s case

CA Rule 11.2 lets the Party Board temporarily amend the CA Rules to address unforeseen, unexpected or unusual circumstances affecting CAs. A province-wide referendum could qualify.

The response

That’s the strongest route, and it has conditions. No temporary amendment binds CAs until it’s emailed to members and posted on the party website. Its effective time is determined by the Party Board, subject to those requirements; its temporary effect ends no later than the next AGM, where it may expire or be ratified, amended or rejected. With the AGM on November 27–29, members would decide almost immediately.

“This isn’t discipline under the Code of Conduct.”

The party’s case

The Code’s free-expression protection is about discipline under the Code. A signing requirement is a governance procedure, not a disciplinary proceeding.

The response

Code 2.8 doesn’t limit itself to actions taken under the Code. It says CA board members are not to be reprimanded or disciplined by the Party, the Party Board or a CA board for exercising their freedom of expression, unless it’s a Criminal Code offence. Removing an elected president is discipline in substance, whatever article is cited. The Membership Rules point the same way: respectful disagreement isn’t cause for discipline. Whether declining to sign counts as “expression” is open to argument, and a dispute panel would have to decide it.

“Everyone is being treated the same.”

The party’s case

Every president is asked to sign, and anyone who doesn’t will be treated the same way. Consistency is fair.

The response

Consistency matters. But applying a requirement to everyone equally doesn’t make it authorized. The first question is whether the rules allow it at all.

What the party’s arbitrators have said before

Calgary-Varsity CA v. UCP (July 2025)

At the 2024 AGM, members passed a rule barring registered lobbyists from CA boards. A sitting Calgary-Varsity president was told to step down. The CA challenged it, and the party’s dispute panel sided with the party: the new rule applied right away, to people already in office.

The panel’s reason matters here. It said it had no power to override the clearly expressed will of the membership. Sitting CA officers can be bound by a new rule when members make that rule. In this case, members haven’t voted on anything.

Read the decision (PDF)

What members can do

If you’re a member

  1. Read the rules for yourself. Every document is linked below.
  2. Ask your CA president what they’ve been asked to sign, and whether they’ve been told what happens if they don’t.
  3. Watch your inbox. A temporary change to the CA Rules isn’t binding until it’s emailed to members and posted on the party site.
  4. If you’re attending the AGM, be ready. A temporary change has effect only until it expires or is ratified, amended or rejected at the next AGM.

If a dispute comes up

The party’s General Dispute Resolution Process covers disputes over how the Bylaws and constitutional documents are read, including disputes between a CA and the party. Any ten members acting together, or a CA, can file a notice of dispute. The process has to follow the rules of natural justice: fair, balanced, open and transparent.

The rules are only as strong as the members who know them.

Editorial Disclaimer

The views presented are the personal opinions of Christopher Scott, presented by Let’s Talk Alberta. This is not legal advice. Rule references are drawn from the party’s published governance documents, linked above.

Questions or Corrections?

Questions, corrections, or want to talk it through in person?